I guess "chick flick" generally describes movies women tend to drag unwilling men to go see. However, the term also can be used for movies primarily about women, and since the women in these films are neither scantily clad nor kicking ass, men tend to avoid those as well.
Well I wasn't going to avoid the two that Megan picked out for us this past week. Megan hardly ever wants to see movies. She's more of a television watcher. I'm the opposite, so when she gets in the mood for film, I'm very willing to go with her choices. Coincidentally, both featured Shirley Mcclain in supporting roles as grandmothers.
The first was the romantic comedy
Rumor Has It... starring Jennifer Aniston. It was directed by Rob Reiner famous for
This Is Spinal Tap and
The Princess Bride, two movies I could easily describe as groundbreaking. Also the premise, about a woman who finds out her family was the inspiration for the movie
The Graduate, looked promising.
Unfortunately, it failed to deliver. Aniston had a real opportunity to play a dark, complex character, a woman trying to find herself. I don't know whether it's her good girl image or her own acting limitations, but she absolutely did not make this person interesting at all. I could not help thinking about how another actress, for example Catherine Keener, could delve further into the edginess while still pulling off the comedy and like-ability. Also, there was no chemistry in the supposed romance between her character and Kevin Costner's. Shirley Mcclain was wasted in this film, playing one of those generic sassy grandmothers, past her prime seductress years. Add on the missed opportunity to have fun with
The Graduate references and a completely forced ending, and I was about grade this movie with a D. However, since it really wasn't aspiring to be more than a fun, distracting, popcorn, romantic comedy, I really can't give it anything lower than a
C-.
The second was
In Her Shoes directed by Curtis "never made the same movie twice" Hanson. It was classic chick flick material, about the relationship between two sisters: one dumb and pretty, the other smart and not so pretty. The film, however, elevated the material well beyond its stereotypical premise. Cameron Diaz, successfully taking advantage of her party-girl image and inherent hotness, added dimension to her dark, troubled character. Both Toni Collette and Shirley MacLain were wonderful as well, the latter playing a grandmother with too much regret in her past. Curtis Hanson, who always captured locations well in his previous work (Los Angeles, Pittsburgh, Detroit) did a wonderful job immersing me in Philadelphia. Some minor flaws, like a rushed third act and two scenes going too far to demonstrate one character's lack of intelligence, left me giving the movie a
B+.
So it was fun, watching films in a genre I usually don't, and I'm definitely happy I had a chance to see In Her Shoes. Up next for me is the Queen Latifa vehicle, Last Holiday.